Who Gains From a Minimum Margin on Cardano Stake Pools?

On a pool reward of 1,000 ADA, a 5% margin could leave 950 ADA or 788.50 ADA to distribute by stake. The difference comes down to whether the operator keeps the fixed fee.

By SongMarketCap

Updated:

Cardano News - Who Gains From a Minimum Margin on Cardano Stake Pools?

Markus, a Cardano Forum moderator, published a simulation on November 18 examining how a minimum stake pool margin could change the rewards operators and delegators receive. Using data from epoch 666, he compared minimum margins of 4% and 6% and modeled a 5% floor across pools of different sizes. He chose those rates to illustrate possible outcomes. Setting a binding minimum would require a Cardano governance decision.

Markus estimated that pools already charging a 100% margin collected about five-sixths of all variable pool fees. Those operators would retain the same share of a given reward under any of the three scenarios. For public pools competing for delegators with a 0% margin, the outcome would depend on both the new rate and what they charge as a fixed fee.

Where the Variable Fees Go

Of roughly 2,650 pools registered in epoch 666, Markus identified about 1,230 that had produced at least one block in the preceding 18 epochs, or about three months. He estimated that operators collected approximately 1.5 million ADA in fees per epoch. Fixed fees accounted for about 300,000 ADA and variable fees for the remaining 1.2 million. Delegators’ rewards fall outside those figures.

According to Markus, about 1 million ADA of that 1.2 million went to pools charging a 100% margin. Cardano pays the operator its fixed fee first, then applies the margin to the remaining reward. At 100%, the operator receives the full balance. Lowering the fixed fee would simply move some of that income from one fee category to the other.

Markus identified some exchange-operated pools in this group. An exchange can distribute rewards to customers through its own platform, so its on-chain margin alone does not reveal how much an individual customer received.

When Does 5% Pay More Than 170 ADA?

Consider a public pool that charges a fixed fee of 170 ADA and a 0% margin. If it earns 1,000 ADA in an epoch, the operator collects 170 ADA in fees. The remaining 830 ADA goes to those who delegated to the pool, in proportion to their stake. That includes the pool owners if they delegated their own ADA.

Suppose Cardano allows a zero fixed fee, the operator adopts it, and the pool charges a 5% margin. On the same 1,000 ADA reward, the operator would collect 50 ADA, leaving 950 ADA to distribute. A delegator with 1% of the pool’s stake would receive 9.50 ADA for that epoch, up from 8.30 ADA.

cardano-pool-fees-table

Pool reward for the epochOperator fees at 170 ADA + 0%Operator fees at 0 ADA + 5%Change in amount distributed by stake1,000 ADA170 ADA50 ADA120 ADA more3,400 ADA170 ADA170 ADANo change10,000 ADA170 ADA500 ADA330 ADA less

At 3,400 ADA in gross rewards, a 5% margin exactly replaces the 170 ADA fixed fee. At 4%, the pool would need to earn 4,250 ADA to collect the same amount. At 6%, it would need about 2,833 ADA. These thresholds compare fee income. Whether an operator earns enough to cover hosting, hardware, and labor depends on its expenses.

Would Operators Give Up the Fixed Fee?

An operator could also keep the 170 ADA fee. On a 1,000 ADA reward, a 5% margin would then apply to the remaining 830 ADA, adding 41.50 ADA to the operator’s fee income. That would leave 788.50 ADA to distribute by stake. Two pools could therefore advertise the same 5% margin and pay their delegators different amounts on identical gross rewards.

In one scenario, Markus assumed that operators who had previously cut their fixed fee from 340 ADA to around 170 ADA would follow the minimum down to zero. Those still charging 340 ADA would keep their fee.

Cardano’s earlier fee reduction offers a basis for testing that assumption. According to research presented by Manvir Schneider and Juan Ignacio Beccuti Vázquez, about 24% of the pools they tracked had adopted the lower 170 ADA fee by epoch 500. Roughly one in three smaller pools made the cut, compared with one in six to seven larger pools.

For a small pool that produces blocks infrequently, lowering the fixed fee can give delegators a larger share in an epoch when the pool earns a reward. The operator gives up income from that same payout. The simulation measures how much changes hands. Whether a lower fee attracts enough additional stake to offset that loss depends on how delegators respond.

[NEWSBREAK]

What Cardano Would Have to Change

Cardano Improvement Proposal 23 defines minPoolMargin, the lowest percentage fee a pool can charge. A separate parameter, minPoolCost, sets the minimum fixed fee, currently 170 ADA. The Hard Fork Working Group includes the margin parameter in the scope of Dijkstra’s protocol version 12. Intersect’s rollout plan allows the fee rule to take effect with that upgrade or later in the Dijkstra era.

The proposal recommends an initial margin floor of 0%, allowing pools to retain their existing rates. Lowering the 170 ADA fixed-fee floor would require a separate governance decision. Even if Cardano allowed a zero fixed fee, each pool operator would decide whether to charge it.