Cardano Rejects 22 Million ADA Copper Reserve Proposal
Toto Finance’s request expired with 0.51% DRep support following objections over custody protections, fees, and the proposed Ethereum-to-Cardano token bridge.
By SongMarketCap
Updated:
Toto Finance’s proposal to withdraw 22 million ADA from the Cardano treasury expired on November 15 without securing approval. The proposed Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve would have funded physical copper purchases and infrastructure for representing the metal through blockchain tokens.
Submitted on October 15, the request required approval from delegated representatives and the Constitutional Committee. The company planned to hold the copper, tokenize it through CuTT, and return the proceeds from its eventual sale to the treasury.
DRep Support Fell Far Below the Approval Threshold
Cardanoscan’s expired-action record shows five delegated representatives, known as DReps, voting in favor, 126 against, and eight abstaining. Supporting votes represented approximately 20.02 million ADA, compared with about 2.86 billion ADA in explicit votes against.
Affirmative support reached 0.51% of the voting power counted toward ratification, far below the required 67%. That calculation includes voting power assigned to Always No Confidence and active DReps who did not vote. Abstaining stake is excluded.
The Constitutional Committee separately reviewed compliance with Cardano’s constitution. Tingvard, Leandros BSP, and Ace Alliance found the action unconstitutional. Four members did not vote, leaving the proposal without any of the five affirmative attestations it needed.
The committee’s assessment concerned constitutional requirements. DRep voting rationales also examined the commercial terms, allocation of risk, and expected benefits of the proposed investment.
Representatives Challenged Custody and the Token Bridge
The Cardano Foundation opposed the request in October, questioning the proposed transfer of the full allocation to an account controlled by Toto Finance before independent protections were established.
Toto Finance would have held legal title to the copper. The proposal required custody arrangements and legal safeguards before acquisition, including protections for the treasury’s economic interest. The Foundation raised concerns about how those protections would operate if the company became insolvent, alongside the costs and concentration of treasury exposure in one commodity.
Independent oversight also remained a planned appointment. The proposal identified a U.S. member firm of the PwC network as the preferred provider, but no engagement had been secured.
A November 15 voting rationale from Agora, the DRep operated by Rodrigo Pacini, challenged the technical design. CuTT would first have been issued on Ethereum. Tokens corresponding to treasury-funded copper would then have been locked in Ethereum escrow, with matching native assets issued on Cardano.
Agora questioned the justification for a specialized bridge when the asset could potentially be issued directly on Cardano. Its rationale also argued that the proposal lacked convincing targets for adoption and economic activity, leaving the expected benefits of the infrastructure insufficiently demonstrated.
[NEWSBREAK]
Fees and Operating Costs Shaped the Proposed Return
The budget allocated 14,724,409 ADA, or 66.93% of the request, to COMEX Grade 1 copper cathodes held in an approved U.S. warehouse. Each CuTT token would have represented one independently verified pound of copper.
Another 2.64 million ADA was assigned to technology development and project management, payable against accepted milestones. Approximately 3.53 million ADA covered external operations and assurance, while 441,732 ADA was allocated to execution and 660,000 ADA to independent administration.
Toto Finance could also earn a margin on eligible storage and insurance invoices within the operating budget. Combined compensation could reach approximately 3.36 million ADA, subject to the proposal’s spending limits and payment conditions.
Under its illustrative calculation, copper would have needed to appreciate by roughly 49% for the treasury to recover the original allocation in ADA. That scenario assumed full use of authorized spending ceilings, an unchanged ADA-to-dollar exchange rate, and no additional sale costs. Actual recovery would have depended on all three variables.
The request also competed for capacity under Cardano’s cumulative withdrawal limit of 500 million ADA through approximately July 2027. An October 16 tally put commitments at about 457.4 million ADA. Against that dated snapshot, Toto’s request represented more than half of the remaining allowance.
The proposed reserve targeted an 18-to-24-month holding period, followed by liquidation by month 36. Toto Finance would have been required to return realized net sale proceeds, unused funds, and unearned payments to the treasury within that period. The obligation carried no guarantee of recovering the full 22 million ADA.